To juice or papoose is the question
July 1, 2010
No one likes the idea of seeing a child being restrained. Especially not at the dental office. But on the same hand, if a child is admitted to a hospital, has thousands of dollars spent to knock them out with potentially risky gas, and is in need of a procedure that takes only minutes to perform, which care is the right one?
Notorious press has given the papoose board a bad name. Granted, its utilization can be abused, especially as seen in the story that was profiled on ABC’s 20/20. General anesthesia isn’t without its opponents as well, especially when a child dies.
With that somber note hanging in the air, you may want to revisit David After Dentist and pick yourself up with a little sedation dentistry humor. Even if you don’t agree that his dad should have ever posted the video on YouTube, it’s still so freakin’ funny.
Children who can’t be cooperative still need a means of getting their dentistry done, so pedodontists must make choices that sometimes include the use of papoose boards or general anesthesia. For entertainment’s sake, let’s just call this polarizing dilemma by another name: Hugs vs. Drugs.
| Hugs | Drugs | |
| Familiar name | Papoose board restraint | “Knocked out with the mask” |
| Kinder-sounding euphemism | Protective stabilization | Inhalation anesthesia |
| Risks |
|
|
| Benefits | Can be used quickly and inexpensively without much training | Instantaneous and complete patient control |
| Perception | Brute force and inhumane treatment seen in Medicare clinics | Clean, modern care paid for by inscos and private payer |


We were impressed that when put on the spot between inaugural balls today, President Barack Obama was able to outline his plan to give all people in the United States of America the right to a beautiful, healthy smile. The big question is: just 





